Thursday, November 20, 2008

Beach Trashed During Religous Ceremony

Congressman Pushes for Enforcement at Jamaica Bay

By Conor Greene

When a local congressman arrived at a beach at the foot of the Joseph P. Addabbo Bridge, he expected to take part in a cleanup of the typical debris found along the waterfront. Instead, he was surprised to find the area littered with garbage left behind from religious ceremonies performed there on a regular basis.

Congressman Anthony Weiner (D-Brooklyn, Queens) organized the cleanup on the beach, which is along the Jamaica Bay and is part of Gateway National Park, last Friday. When he arrived, he found that the problem extends far beyond discourteous fishermen or beachgoers. Instead, the beach was littered with red and yellow flags, dozens of coconuts and other remnants from religious ceremonies performed by Hindus and other groups.

After hearing from local residents that such ceremonies take place on a regular basis, especially during certain times of year, and being told of headless goats being left beneath the bridge, Congressman Weiner decided that a combination of education and enforcement is needed to curtail this activity.

“There has to be some sense that this is a national park. We want people to enjoy it, but there has to be a balance,” he said, adding that individuals who leave trash behind are “abusing their rights as visitors to the park.” He called upon park police to begin “regular enforcement,” including issuing tickets to offending visitors. “The people are not the issue,” he added, wondering aloud, “Is it legal to cut the head off a goat in a national park?”

Residents on hand for the cleanup, who say the activity has been going on for several years, suggested placing signs in the parking lot informing visitors of the rules. Edgardo Castillo, a park ranger with the National Parks Service, said there are plans to install gates across the parking lot enterance to prevent late night visitors at the beach area.

“We need a combination of education and enforcement,” said Weiner. “At the end of the day, enforcement needs to be done.” He admitted that prior to his visit, he “didn’t fully grasp that there are chronic offenders” who are leaving behind a “shrine of garbage… in the name of religion.”

For local residents, efforts to punish those who leave trash the on beach could not come soon enough, said Barbara Toborg, a Broad Channel resident and member of the American Littoral Society. She told Congressman Weiner that park police “are not interested” in issuing summonses to beachgoers, something the lawmaker now hopes to correct.

Patti Reilly, acting superintendent for the Jamaica Bay section of the Gateway National Recreation Area, told the Daily News that crews have a difficult time keeping up with the amount of garbage left behind.

“We’ve been working with the communities, trying to have them better understand and educate them about the impact of leaving articles from their religious ceremonies,” she told the paper. “From time to time, we have seen animal carcasses and have removed them quickly… None of that is permitted,” she said.

While the religious followers believe they are making offerings to the sea, Congressman Weiner had a different view. “They are essentially throwing garbage into the water,” he said, holding up a handful of debris.


Anonymous said...

Lying and jumping to conclusions and posting innocent people's pictures who are just praying is racism, and you are targetting them. I expect those group of individuals to take full action on this. This is Non Sense!!!!!!!!

Anonymous said...

Although every one should respect all religions, which is what this country was built on. Howver when religious customs interfere with the general welfare of all then there should be rules and laws to consider the general welfare of the public.

In addition, when human cremated remains are scattered, the United States Environmental Protection Agency laws require that the scattering takes place three nautical miles from land. A burial permit or cremation certificate must be filed and sent to EPA within 30 days and must include the details of the scattering.
See GPO link for codes

Anonymous said...

I fish that area and am always disgusted by the garbage these people leave behind in the name of religion. This is a national park to be enjoyed by everyone. Why should I have to look at the mess other people leave behind. The park police are also a joke - they don't provide any enforcement. Freedom of religion is always used as an excuse. I guess if my religion required me to sacrifice live animals on the beach that should be allowed in the name of religion. Better yet, maybe I'll form a new religion that requires mass orgies and drug parties on the beach - it's my religion so the tough on everyone else.

Anonymous said...

Maybe a section of the beach should be designated for religious services with rules in place to clean up after performing any ritual.

We should not degrade other people's religion if we don't understand the reason for doing certain things. At the same time we should all respect each other and clean up after ourselves.